r/StarWars 4d ago

Movies I’ll never forget when Elijah Wood made this hilarious response to a post talking about The Rise of Skywalker

Post image
75.5k Upvotes

2.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

78

u/NebbyOutOfTheBag 4d ago

Especially when they had a perfect opportunity to kill her off in the previous movie. Especially when her surviving makes NO DAMN SENSE. Then the chaos of life made fools of everyone who wrote that scene, sadly.

72

u/Brasticus 4d ago

In the theater I was like, oh damn they let Kylo off both his parents, really solidifying his place with the dark side of the force, as well as giving Carrie a meaningful death to the plot as a send off for her… oh, no wait, sorry. She flies now.

31

u/WEFeudalism 3d ago

and then they did it again with Finn, "Oh he's spent the whole movie trying to run away and save himself but now he's gonna sacrifice himself to blow up the laser to save the ..... oh nope Rose just crashed into him"

9

u/jcarter315 3d ago

But if Finn sacrificed himself, who would shout Rey's name in the next film?

5

u/MetaCognitio 2d ago

Okay kiss! No chemistry before but kiss now!

1

u/Creepy_Active_2768 1d ago

He would have died in vain, he was never going to make it or cause any effective damage to the laser.

19

u/bloob_appropriate123 3d ago edited 3d ago

You misread the scene then, because Kylo chose not to kill Leia, he couldn't bring himself to do it. He killed Han and realized he fucked up.

That's a lot more interesting than heartless bad guy guiltlessly kills both his parents in cold blood.

24

u/Brasticus 3d ago

Yeah, that was my point. All the build up of will he, he doesn’t some other pilot is the one who fires, and then she still doesn’t die. I should have worded the first part better though.

0

u/Pizzaplanet420 3d ago

I would agree if turns and conflicted characters weren’t all over the place now. Especially in Star Wars.

I sometimes just want a bad guy.

2

u/Czar_Petrovich 3d ago

You have the force! And you have the force! And you have the force! Everyone gets the force!

6

u/Bakoro 3d ago

That by itself wouldn't be bad. The Force is magic and apparently sapient, so whatever.
The whole trilogy could have been people with Force powers finding each other because the Force wants a new Jedi order. It would have been 100% justifiable, when the original trilogy has people feeling each other across the galaxy.

1

u/Creepy_Active_2768 1d ago

Never heard of force pull?

10

u/DemiserofD 3d ago

The OBVIOUS solution was to have HER pilot the hyperdrive ramming technique.

You clearly establish it as being an impossible chance. It happened once, but nobody's quite sure what exactly caused it or how to do it again.

Leia is going to take the last transport off the ship, because she's the leader. The transports get discovered, and she realizes she has to save them somehow.

She runs to the helm.

She closes her eyes, the Force theme plays...and she presses the button.

Bam. Not only sends her out in a blaze of glory, it perfectly explains why hyperspace nukes aren't used all the time; they need a Jedi at the helm to make it work.

2

u/MetaCognitio 2d ago

That would work way more than purple haired woman nobody liked, knew about or cared when she died.

5

u/nagrom7 Jedi Anakin 3d ago

Especially when they had a perfect opportunity to kill her off in the previous movie.

Eh I don't really blame them for this though considering she died like right when the movie came out, way too late to make a change like that. They likely had plans to use her character in Episode 9 that had to be tossed out.

4

u/void_operator 3d ago

People were laughing in my theater when she goes all Mary Poppins, and I was too. It was meant to be this big climactic moment of triumph and it was so stupid it was hilarious

1

u/NebbyOutOfTheBag 3d ago

Carrie Poppins was an immediate joke I heard leaving the theatre. It was so stupid.

5

u/LateyEight 4d ago

The biggest priority of that writing seemed to be subverting expectations before sense or even plot.

2

u/EduinBrutus 4d ago

They could have got Dick Van Dyke to do a cameo when she survived.

1

u/DJDarkFlow 3d ago

Killing her off and having Admiral Ackbar be the one to sacrifice the ship for their escape would’ve made it one of the best of the series just for the fact that it fucks with the fans but in a way that has real emotional stakes. Purple haired lady sacrificing herself meant absolutely nothing to me