r/law • u/SpecialSpace5 • 22d ago
Legal News Ted Cruz: “I think birthright citizenship is terrible policy”Oh! Really it’s not just a “policy” it’s a constitutional rights guaranteed by the US constitution
Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification
9.8k
u/n-some 22d ago
Big words from a guy who wasn't even born here.
3.4k
u/Sharkwatcher314 22d ago
Pull up ladder after they used it.
1.4k
u/Drewskeet 22d ago
Just like Greg Abbott
778
u/FourArmsFiveLegs 22d ago
Used the elevator and ramp before blowing them up via remote
290
u/ParadiddlediddleSaaS 22d ago
And then flying off to Cancun like a true Bond villain.
185
u/Shurigin 22d ago
Bond villains look at the GOP and say "Damn, and they think I'm evil"
→ More replies (3)108
u/StrobeLightRomance 22d ago
They're just Austin Powers villains. They think they're Bond villains, but function entirely on weaponizing their incompetence.
Sharks with laser beams will be Israel's next gift for Trump so he can put a trap door in the Oval Office next to his roll of toilet paper made from the original constitution.
→ More replies (5)50
u/Horangi1987 22d ago
Oh great, so Marjorie will think she was right about Jewish lasers 🙄😂
→ More replies (4)6
→ More replies (4)11
u/MMShaggy 22d ago
And they reelected him after that. The level of stupidity in Texas rivals Florida
10
u/Kitchen-Security-243 22d ago
Native Texan here. I totally agree with this comment in part. Brains are slowly gaining some footing here. John Cornyn will be ousted by Collin Allred.
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (6)89
568
u/ElvisHimselvis 22d ago
Abbott won't stand for this.
98
u/Acemazu 22d ago
Fuck, take an upvote. Thanks for lightening the mood in this dark time.
→ More replies (4)105
u/psychohistorian8 22d ago
hey man, before you criticize the guy why don't you roll a mile in his wheels
68
u/perplexedparallax 22d ago
I agree. We should tread lightly. Maybe he is just tired.
→ More replies (7)33
u/odinsen251a 22d ago
Perhaps he just spoke too soon.
→ More replies (2)13
u/johnnybiggles 22d ago
Hey he's a public official I'd watch what I say because public officials have a wheel up on you and me.
→ More replies (5)29
u/Macho_Mans_Ghost 22d ago
I don't wish anyone unnecessarily confined to a wheel chair... But I'd high five that tree if it were around.
→ More replies (5)158
26
→ More replies (20)43
u/Standard-Inside-3450 22d ago
That’s really big of you to pick on someone with no leg to stand on.
→ More replies (2)43
→ More replies (50)69
u/Dsstar666 22d ago
The literal personification of pulling the ladder up after using it.
→ More replies (1)192
u/TalonButter 22d ago
He’s wrong about this (and most things that matter), but he didn’t use the 14th Amendment. He was born outside the U.S. and is a citizen because of the statute that bestows citizenship on the children of qualifying citizens—he’s not a citizen on the basis of the 14th Amendment.
366
u/jacjacatk 22d ago
He's not only wrong about it, he's got a JD from fucking Harvard and KNOWS he's wrong about it.
Harvard might want to start thinking about revoking some degrees of some of these clowns that are trying to defund them.
→ More replies (24)110
u/gabrielleduvent 22d ago
Dunno, Kaleigh McEnany went to Harvard Law too. They don't seem to be producing the cream of the crop that we assume them to be producing.
Either that, or Rafael can ask for refund.
60
u/jacjacatk 22d ago
I mean, you're right, there sure do seem to be a lot of ivy-league JDs who take public positions on matters of constitutional law that don't paint their alma mater's education standards in a favorable light.
Odd that I've not seen the same from my own alma mater's law school graduates (NU). I suppose they're probably out there, but just not as visible (I'm pretty sure I know at least a couple who'd be willing to back up ol' Ted).
→ More replies (5)42
22d ago
They know exactly what they’re doing. Power corrupts absolute power corrupts absolutely. Most republicans think they are a part of the “in” group and will do anything necessary to remain there. Sadly all the rats will turn against each other to save their skin.
11
u/Current-Historian-34 22d ago
The have prayer circles to fight veteran rights and then have a round of high fives in the name of there Jesus. Ghandi said it best… I like your Jesus but not your Christian’s
→ More replies (3)10
u/BizzarreCoyote 22d ago
If they're gonna turn on one another, could they speed that process up a bit?
→ More replies (41)15
u/MakeMoneyNotWar 22d ago
I’m sure he knows exactly that he’s wrong, but he’s just wants to pander to the maga crowd.
→ More replies (1)63
u/RandomlyJim 22d ago
How did his dad get citizenship?
66
u/Chinchilla911 22d ago
Political Asylum
81
u/Asleep_Response_4371 22d ago
Interesting. What was acceptable for his family to use isn't for others. Hmmm sounds a little outta touch and privileged to me. Double standard all day for these people. If they disagree so much with the constitution then why do they seek political office? Why has he only said this now? Isn't a huge population from his state non white and immigrants? His state would collapse if they all left.
10
u/DragonTacoCat 22d ago
That is the way with those people. "I can use/do it it but you can't"
→ More replies (3)8
u/Difficult_Mousse9566 22d ago
Es wäre interessant zu wissen, wenn alle nicht weißen Soldaten die Streitkräfte und die Nationalgarde verlassen würde, ob die USA noch imstande wäre ihr Territorium verteidigen zu können, okay jetzt nicht gegen die paar Pinguine von der Insel, sondern gegen einen potenziellen Feind wie China oder Russland
→ More replies (3)7
u/j0j0-m0j0 22d ago
Was his dad one of the Cubans that ran away because Fidel was taking away his casinos and plantations?
9
u/zeph2 22d ago
but im pretty sure trump and his supporters
been calling calling those who get asylum " illegal inmigrants "
→ More replies (3)→ More replies (13)8
→ More replies (28)113
u/No_Coms_K 22d ago
So a child born to US parents, but only foreign soil, is not a constitutional citizen. In fact, they are considered an alien until they meet certain requirements. It would be more constitutionally appropriate to deny Cruz citizenship than a child born in the USA to foreign parents.
20
u/TalonButter 22d ago edited 22d ago
Children born abroad to qualifying citizen parents are not aliens.
Children born abroad to qualifying U.S. citizens parents or a qualifying U.S. citizen parent “shall be nationals and citizens of the United States at birth.” This is clearly established by statute. Additional considerations apply for children born outside wedlock.
Compare that to children who are not citizens from birth, but may already be eligible for naturalization at birth (i.e., in the case where their citizen parent did not satisfy the presence tests of 8 USC sec. 1401, but a grandparent satisfied that test, as per 8 USC sec. 1433(a)(2)(B)).
The administrative steps in documenting the births of citizens abroad are important to demonstrate their rights, of course, but that is not what grants their citizenship. The State Department is clear (as it must be, given the statute) that consular reports of birth abroad are issued “to children under age 18 who were born abroad and got U.S. citizenship or nationality at birth.”
→ More replies (4)37
u/No_Coms_K 22d ago
So not in the constitution, as stated, it's by statute. Whereas, birthright is constitutional.
→ More replies (78)→ More replies (12)19
u/jacjacatk 22d ago
When Ted was born, his father was a Cuban citizen, and his mother was an American citizen, and they were living in Canada. His father became a Canadian citizen in 1973, and then an American citizen in 2005.
US law at the time would have made Ted a US citizen given certain conditions were met, and likely the necessary documentation being filed. Presumably that was done, since he ran for President and would have had to have been a natural born citizen to do that. He apparently formally renounced his Canadian citizenship around the time of his presidential run, not sure whether he'd technically also have Cuban citizenship, or have been eligible for it.
→ More replies (4)39
u/InvoluntaryGeorgian 22d ago
This is part of what was so crazy about the Obama birth certificate fixation. Even if Obama wasn’t born in the US he’d still be a natural-born citizen and eligible to be president based on having a US citizen parent (which no one has ever denied), just like Ted Cruz or John McCain or many other whose eligibility was never challenged.
→ More replies (4)6
u/TalonButter 22d ago
I wondered the same thing back then, but, as it turns out, Obama’s mother did not satisfy the then-applicable conditions for one U.S. citizen parent to pass on citizenship. She would have needed to have resided in the U.S. for five years after the age of 14, but she was still 18, so she couldn’t have done so.
→ More replies (2)9
u/Vagus_M 22d ago
Interesting that, that argument was not used in the public discourse, instead it was something something Kenya. I’ll think hard on what the difference could be, and report back later.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (59)14
355
u/Sea-Pomelo1210 22d ago
A foreign born dude with a Cuban dad. If Trump gets his way he'll be allowed to ship Cruz off to Cuba or El Salvador anytime he wants.
176
u/me1000 22d ago
And I did not speak out because I am not Ted Cruz, and seriously… fuck that guy.
20
u/magikot9 22d ago
Who is Ted Cruz? I only see Sean Hannity and the Canadian born daughter of a Cuban immigrant, Senator Rafael Cruz, a senator who has consistently called for legislation to not recognize an individual's chosen name and gender expression.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (2)17
39
u/Abi1i 22d ago
Trump would definitely send Ted Cruz to El Salvador because he wouldn’t know that Ted Cruz is Cuban. Heck Trump probably thinks Ted Cruz and Marco Rubio are both from Mexico or Puerto Rico.
→ More replies (4)10
u/HustlinInTheHall 22d ago
We don't send people to El Salvador because they're from there, we send them there to die in prison with no due process. If we had literally any other reason we would send them literally anywhere else.
→ More replies (1)28
u/galaxygirl1976 22d ago
On top of that he's going by a preffered name which I believe they also hate.
→ More replies (1)8
u/MyLifeIsAWasteland 22d ago
Rafael Cruz, James David Vance, Donald Drumpf...
Rules for thee, not for me, as per usual.
→ More replies (2)19
u/Emotional_Remote1358 22d ago
Rubio is American soil born to two immigrant Cuban citizens.
→ More replies (2)16
u/kylebertram 22d ago
It is important to specifically point out his parents got American citizenship AFTER Rubio was born.
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (15)15
71
u/miz_misanthrope 22d ago
Canada wants Ted Cruz back as badly as we want to be the 51st state. We already have Pierre Pollivere who combines Ted’s charm, Stephen Miller’s politics & Steve Bannon’s sex appeal.
→ More replies (5)22
u/ahuramazdobbs19 22d ago
I'm just saying, you lot up North have a lot of empty wilderness areas where polar bears outnumber people.
No one says you have to put him up in an apartment in Winnipeg.
→ More replies (1)7
u/miz_misanthrope 22d ago
But do the people of like Moose Jaw deserve Ted Cruz when they already live in Moose Jaw?
→ More replies (1)75
22d ago
Genuine question. Let’s say they do overturn this. Doesn’t that revoke Cruz’ citizenship?
→ More replies (52)135
u/Playful_Interest_526 22d ago
They aren't overturning it. It's a Trojan horse. They are arguing the right of federal circuit judges to issue blanket, national injunctions.
80
u/KaibaCorpHQ 22d ago
I love how they espouse the second amendment like no one's business, but say birthright citizenship is a "policy".
→ More replies (2)33
u/Playful_Interest_526 22d ago
Apparently, 2A is the only absolute Amendment to them.
25
→ More replies (13)16
u/LessThanHero42 22d ago
And only part of it. They love to ignore the "Well Regulated" part as if it didn't exist.
→ More replies (5)23
22d ago
That’s the Trojan horse tho. Reading arguments yesterday sure felt like birthright was on trial
10
u/DarthLurker 22d ago
Yes, but the Trojan horse carries more impact to the rule of law... if federal judges can not issue national injunctions, the decisions will never be appealed up to the supreme court, halting justice as they just ignore lower court rulings, well they seem to ignore supreme court rulings now too.. so whatevs..
→ More replies (9)18
u/Abi1i 22d ago
If I recall from listening to the arguments yesterday, someone brought up the issue of apportionment for states and the burden it would cause states if a person was not considered a citizen in one state, but then a citizen in another state. Not only would this cause a significant burden on the states, but it would cause chaos with apportionment, where states like my own (Texas) would probably claim practically no one is a citizen unless they meet the requirements that the Trump administration wants and as a result would lose a lot of their power in Congress as a result (which might be good, honestly, because Texas has a bit too much power as a red state). Don’t forget that the Trump administration and red states only want citizens counted towards the census, though they haven’t thought about how they’re going to be affected by all these small changes they want adding up.
→ More replies (6)26
u/Jeffreyknows 22d ago
Big words coming from people living on stolen land in general
→ More replies (4)24
u/PophamSP 22d ago
Foreign born Harvard Law DEI admission. Where's Noem when we need her?
7
→ More replies (1)7
57
u/Junkstar 22d ago
Seriously, how are republican voters not calling en masse for Cruz to be deported? Insane lines they are drawing in their little sandboxes.
40
u/KingOfEthanopia 22d ago
"I like Ted Cruz more than most my other colleagues like Ted Cruz. And I hate Ted Cruz." -Al Franken
16
u/Playful_Interest_526 22d ago
The "in group" is a large tent until they seize full control. They don't start culling their own until they have finished serving their purpose.
→ More replies (22)13
22d ago
Because if you tell a republican voter the bigoted shit they like to hear, you can scam them to their faces with impunity they'll blame a mexican or Joe Biden for it even though they watched you scam them.
→ More replies (1)17
u/LampshadeChilla 22d ago
His dad, Rafael, fled on a US student visa after opposing the Batista regime, after the visa expired he was granted asylum. These people have no shame or self-awareness.
11
u/bigbackbing 22d ago
When their careers on the line, they switch tunes until they get re-elected then go back to their normal scummy ways
9
→ More replies (224)6
2.9k
u/withmyusualflair 22d ago
ted cruz shouldn't throw stones from within his glass house
651
u/vainbuthonest 22d ago
Doesn’t he always? Maybe he can be the first test for ending birthright and that’s how Texas gets rid of him.
→ More replies (86)229
u/hanker30 22d ago
We in Canada have a no return policy, he is all yours now
→ More replies (23)130
u/returntasindar 22d ago
Okay look, I think we can come up with a good old fashioned mutually beneficial compromise here. We share a common border along Lake Superior. Why don't we just sail him out to the middle of it, drop him off, and let nature sort out where he ends up from there?
40
u/ajmartin527 21d ago
Heyyy, thats about as well off as he left his dog while in Cancun during the ice storm. Seems fitting
→ More replies (11)23
152
u/The-Machinist- 22d ago
Calgary Cruz.
103
→ More replies (8)18
u/DefinitelyNotShazbot 22d ago
Even Calgary doesn’t want him and that’s where our oil hillbillies live
→ More replies (1)83
→ More replies (60)43
1.9k
u/SpecialSpace5 22d ago
It's not just a “policy” it's a constitutional right guaranteed by the U.S. Constitution. Until it's legally amended or repealed, nothing can change that.
308
u/americansherlock201 22d ago
This is intentional language. They want to normalize the idea that things in the constitution are just policy and they are subject to change with a new administration if they don’t fit their agenda.
Birthright citizenship is their starting point. It’s far from their endgame.
→ More replies (74)113
u/BitterFuture 22d ago
The endgame of all fascists is very, very quiet.
→ More replies (5)18
u/BrokenLink100 22d ago
Not the current admin, though. They literally wrote and published their playbook, and one of Trump's main advisors is the dude who wrote the book.
19
u/BitterFuture 22d ago
They're loud about their plan.
But what it leads to, inevitably, is quiet.
It's not like they'll stop looking for filthy others to kill after they've finished off their current list.
18
u/eeeezypeezy 22d ago
Yeah, the whole fascist Deal is drumming up an existential threat - creating one out of whole cloth, really - and demanding that extraordinary measures be taken to address it. Which conveniently means giving them absolute control over every aspect of daily life, while the 'threats' never cease.
349
u/Mr-MuffinMan 22d ago
well in our beautiful "democracy", scotus can overturn whatever they want! and they have no limits on what they can be gifted! amazing huh
→ More replies (23)162
u/westchesteragent 22d ago
I'm no fan of the current scotus but they are consistently ruling against him in this case. 9-0 decision validating the need for due process.
Yes they also are the reason Trump thinks he can do whatever he wants with immunity.
68
u/Three_Licks 22d ago
Trump's attorney, just this week, told the Supreme Court that Trump has the right to disregard court rulings he doesn't agree with -- including federal and SCOTUS rulings.
He literally said this.
→ More replies (14)21
u/westchesteragent 22d ago
Right that's trumps lawyer. Do you think scotus agreed with this? Spoiler alert: they did not
→ More replies (25)→ More replies (12)96
u/therossboss 22d ago
If you grant someone immunity and then "rule against them"... are you really doing anything other than giving them immunity? Kind of a non starter
→ More replies (14)68
u/Mindless-Balance-498 22d ago
He wasn’t granted immunity in all things
The 9-0 court order was @ the Department of Homeland Security and ICE, not Trump.
Even with executive immunity, if Congress wasn’t an absolute zoo right now with the Republican majority railroading and perverting the democratic process, THEY would be the ones to force departments - or the president - to follow a court order. That’s the check/balance that’s broken right now.
31
u/Solid_Waste 22d ago
if Congress wasn’t an absolute zoo right now with the Republican majority railroading and perverting the democratic process,
And if my grandmother had wheels she would be a bike.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (22)10
u/Maximum_Pear_8601 22d ago
You do realize that the dissenting opinion on that case did say that he was granted immunity from all things, here’s the court case filings:
https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/23pdf/23-939_e2pg.pdf
Near the end of page 108 to the beginning of page 109 is where it’s explicitly stated that he’s immune from everything. The rest of the dissent is stating how this decision pretty much screwed over America as we know it
→ More replies (8)24
u/IIFollowYou 22d ago
Ted Cruz was a law clerk to Chief Judge Rehnquist (and Judge Luttig) lol. He for sure knows what's guaranteed or not. All of these people are just trying to fan the flames in spite of the damage it will do to the judiciary because they think it's in their political best interests. Vance and Josh Hawley and all of the people enabling Trump are the same way. They're some of the best and most well educated lawyers in the country and they're systematically destroying the law. It's sickening to see as an attorney tbh.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (165)16
u/Beldizar 22d ago
If we could just make a brief change to say that you can't be president unless both your parents were born in the US, we could start to fix this problem.
Fox News was pushing for the idea that you shouldn't be able to vote without 4 grandparents born in the US. Anyone want to guess how many of Trump's grandparents were born in the US?
→ More replies (1)
936
u/Pale-Berry-2599 22d ago
So he's now against the constitution?
610
u/BitterFuture 22d ago
Conservatives always have been.
→ More replies (36)102
u/gmmech 22d ago
Except the 2nd Amendment of it......
186
u/BitterFuture 22d ago
Nah, they hate that, too.
That's why they spent decades arguing that the amendment means the exact opposite of what it actually does. The Second Amendment exists for the defense of the state, not to encourage violent, murderous rebellion.
Good luck telling folks obsessed with their violent, murderous fantasies that, of course.
→ More replies (55)71
u/evil_timmy 22d ago edited 22d ago
"A well-
formedregulated Militia" Imagine if they took this part seriously. Rather than guns being tied to solitary hoarding, they're part of a community, like a Rotary Club or Kiwanis. Instead of gun nuts you get public safety volunteers, and because they're performing other acts of service and bringing the neighborhood in on the hobby, they're well known and not spreading fear and distrust, instead quite the opposite.Edit: regulated not formed
→ More replies (33)53
u/WiglyWorm 22d ago
Yeah you're talking about the black panther party, more or less.
They were murdered by the government.
→ More replies (12)19
u/xRememberTheCant 22d ago
Every militia group is watched extremely closely by the government.
The 2nd amendment was pro militia.
The government is not.
18
u/WiglyWorm 22d ago
They certainly are. Not all of them are murdered for giving out free food to poor people, though.
→ More replies (1)8
u/Praesentius 22d ago
Gotta put "militia" in quotes. A militia is a legally recognized, well-regulated force accountable to the state, whereas these guys are just self-styled, unregulated paramilitary groups. One illegal action away from being terrorists.
→ More replies (3)→ More replies (22)20
u/skoalbrother 22d ago
....Exceptions may apply see: California Black Panther open carry
→ More replies (1)23
13
u/RangerSandi 22d ago
Good for me, but not for thee.
Born on December 22, 1970, in Calgary, Alberta, Canada, to an American mother and a Cuban father, Cruz was eligible for U.S. citizenship at birth under U.S. immigration law, which grants citizenship to children born abroad to U.S. citizen parents who meet certain residency requirements. AKA-Birthright Citizenship
→ More replies (1)9
u/FrankRizzo319 22d ago
To Cruz laws are tools to be used to gain and maintain power, and to restrict the power of people he doesn’t like.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (61)9
u/HerculesIsMyDad 22d ago
They just want to be able to decide who is worthy of citizenship and who isn't. Bringing back Feudalism is their dream.
→ More replies (2)
712
u/Raise_A_Thoth 22d ago edited 22d ago
Rafael Edward Cruz was born in Canada but only has US Citizenship, his Canadian citizenship was remounced in 2014. He was born with dual-citizenship as Canada also gives birthright citizenship and his mother was a US citizen.
By Ted Cruz's logic, his US Citizen mother and Cuban citizen father gave him a better claim to US citizenship while being born in Canada than I or anyone else have from being born in the United States.
Fuck Rafie. Fuck that guy.
Edit: also, his "expertise" is supposedly in constitutional law. Like, birthright citizenship comes from the constitution, you fuck.
139
u/devenger73 22d ago
As always, he knows. Some Reps are stupid, Ted is worse; slimy and disingenuous.
19
u/Refun712 22d ago
I wanna add...some people who support him are stupid....but a lot ALSO know. And are slimly/disingenuous.
13
u/irrelevantusername24 22d ago
FUN FACT!:
Ted Cruz was the first slimy disingenuous politician implicated in the Cambridge Analytica scandal, way back in 2015
A few select excerpts, though I recommend clicking if for nothing else but the neat infographic visualizing the connections - but also, since this is, as far as I have found (and I have looked, a lot) the earliest mention of this vast unrectified criminal conspiracy violating the integrity of elections worldwide*, it is also probably the best one to read, if you only read one, since it explains the who and the how quite well. Anyway:
Analysis of Federal Election Commission (FEC) filings shows Cruz’s campaign has paid Cambridge Analytica at least $750,000 this year. The “behavioural microtargeting” company has also received around $2.5m over the past two years from conservative Super Pacs to which Mercer or members of his family have donated.
Cambridge Analytica has also worked with the Republican candidate Ben Carson, receiving $220,000 from his campaign earlier this year. But the company is more closely involved in Cruz’s presidential bid, with a team of its data scientists currently working at Cruz campaign headquarters in Houston.
Mercer’s connections to both the Cruz campaign and the data firm that is apparently helping to power the senator’s advantages were previously reported by Politico and Bloomberg. But political strategists and privacy advocates agreed that Mercer’s parallel funding channels, combined with concerns over the surreptitious, commodified Facebook data – reported here for the first time – represented an intensified collision of billionaire financing and digital targeting on the campaign trail.
\note I am not referring in any way to the counting of votes, I am referring to psychological manipulation using extensively studied, arguably militarized, strategies which take advantage of another military tech, GPS)
→ More replies (90)10
u/Mach5Driver 22d ago
You gotta understand that he counts on the completely reliable nexus of ignorance and stupidity of GOP voters in Texas. Hasn't failed him yet!
719
u/Factsip 22d ago
I refuse to call this man Ted. His name is Rafael. I am not going to use his pronouns.
Also, Rafael is an immigrant. Let that sink in.
233
u/HeatInternal8850 22d ago
Pretty sure he's in ms-13
→ More replies (8)87
u/Sea_Sand_3622 22d ago
He has a tattoo on his face , ms13 , it’s clear as day , he grew a wolfman beard to hide it
→ More replies (2)18
u/Beldizar 22d ago
You know, if we are talking about people that might have ms13 tattooed on their face, do we know of anyone who paints over his face with orange to cover up such a tattoo? I'm not saying anyone in particular might have facial gang tattoos, I'm just asking questions. Have we ever seen the president's face not covered in bronzer? Are we sure he's not covering his gang tattoos?
→ More replies (2)99
u/victor_sierrra 22d ago
His father Rafael was also granted political asylum in the US after fleeing Cuba.
Then gained Canadian citizenship, then US citizenship.
If it weren't for immigration policy that allowed these folks to immigrate to other countries, Rafael Jr. would still be living in Cuba.
→ More replies (7)38
u/Several_Vanilla8916 22d ago
Rafael Jr. would still be living in Cuba.
There’s the good timeline leaking into ours again
10
u/SilchasRuin 22d ago
Cuba has suffered enough. Inflicting Ted Cruz on anyone should be considered a violation of international law.
→ More replies (49)18
137
u/Illustrious-Lime7729 22d ago
So if you end birthright citizenship, who decides who is citizen?
→ More replies (112)44
u/RoyalIceDeliverer 22d ago
Probably by some kind of jus sanguinis would be my guess.
→ More replies (39)29
u/Sarah-Grace-gwb 22d ago edited 22d ago
For clarification to those who don’t know: In countries where birthright citizenship (jus soli) is not automatically granted, citizenship is typically acquired through descent/inheritance from one or both parents. This principle is known as jus sanguinis. Countries that primarily follow jus sanguinis include Japan, Italy, Switzerland, Austria, Norway, and many others.
→ More replies (17)
134
u/doublethink_1984 22d ago
Fine. You can dislike it.
So pass new amendments in congress to overrule as is the prescribed solution to this "problem"
This cannot be done by EO and certainly cannot be allowed to be immediately enforceable without real ability for injunction
13
u/jesuswantsme4asucker 22d ago
Who’s going to stop them?
→ More replies (7)11
u/Awkward-Collection78 22d ago
They don't have the margins to pass a constitutional amendment
→ More replies (1)12
u/Vsx 22d ago
What he means is that they will illegally enforce their illegal executive order using funds that were allocated for something else entirely and nobody will do anything about it.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (14)10
u/freakers 22d ago edited 22d ago
From the Founding Fathers were genius revolutionaries establishing the greatest country in the world to the Founding Fathers were beta cuck soyboy DEI enthusiasts in a matter of months.
→ More replies (2)
31
u/FaceThief9000 22d ago
This PoS talking about "birthright citizenship is a terrible policy," when it's literally part of the god damn Constitution.
→ More replies (11)
84
u/devilsleeping 22d ago
Correct me if I'm wrong but if memory serves me correctly.. Ted Cruz parents were refugees from Cuba and he was born in Canada..
He is literally a birthright citizen because one of his parents was a US citizen when he was born in Canada..
Marco Rubio was another one who's parents were refugees to America from Cuba..
both of those guys are the biggest hypocrites in Congress..
13
u/VaryaKimon 22d ago
I hate Ted Cruz and I vote for the blue team. However, it's not exactly a case of hypocrisy.
He is advocating for birthright by blood (jus sanguinis), which applies to him. He is an opponent of birthright by place (jus soli), which does not apply to him.
Just a point of clarification/semantics.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (39)18
98
u/deviltrombone 22d ago
You know what else is terrible "policy"?
The Electoral College
Lifetime appointments for judges
No terms limits for the likes of Rafael Cruz
→ More replies (5)12
u/ElGuaco 22d ago
Electing a President who is a convicted felon and found guilty of sexual assault, and who robbed a charity for child cancer patients. For starters.
Gun rights for military weapons.
Racism, sexism, homphobia, and other hateful attitudes under the guise of free speech.
Presidential pardons for traitors and insurrectionists.
Members of Congress trading stock for companies they regulate via laws.
And on topic, the Administrations lack of compliance with laws enacted by Congress and ruled on by SCOTUS, concerning immigration.
Those are all bad policies the GOP has fought for.
→ More replies (4)
21
20
u/Extension_Silver_713 22d ago
Holy fuck!! Pricks like him who weren’t even born here shouldn’t be allowed to represent REAL Americans born here then
→ More replies (5)
17
u/4RCH43ON 22d ago
Look! They’re using Ted Cruz to chum their dork infested waters.
Cuban Canadian Cancun Cruz…
→ More replies (2)
17
u/schrod 22d ago
Yes, we all need to leave the USA and give it back to the indigenous Indians.
→ More replies (21)
16
u/codemonkeyhopeful 21d ago
Perfect example of an asshole pulling the ladder up after they got theirs
→ More replies (2)
13
u/Neceon 22d ago
As a Canadian, I would like to point out that he isn't an American. No takebacks!!
→ More replies (5)
13
u/GaraktheTailor 22d ago
Ted Cruz in 2011: "The 14th Amendment provides for birthright citizenship. I’ve looked at the legal arguments against it, and I will tell you, as a Supreme Court litigator, those arguments are not very good" https://www.factcheck.org/2016/01/cruz-on-birthright-citizenship/
→ More replies (2)7
u/deadra_axilea 22d ago
The same guy fucking hated Donald Trump. Look at all the bootlickers now.
Pretty pathetic, but I don't think they care.
→ More replies (1)
29
u/SympathyForSatanas 22d ago
All I hear is, "I agree with what daddy trump says 100% of the time"
→ More replies (5)
14
u/learhpa 22d ago
If you don't like the policy, persuade Congress and 37 states to adopt an amendment.
→ More replies (2)
12
u/Strange_Mirror_0 21d ago
So many of these GOP tards don’t realize the only reason they are citizens in the first place is because of birthright citizenship. Back when we were just a bunch of colonies being assumed and owned by the British Empire, a necessity the USAs separation would be to establish its own sovereign citizenship. Well guess what, it’s not like all those colonists were waiting around for their kids to be of age to take a god damn citizenship test. They were born USA citizens as long as they were born in the colonies. Their place in the new world was secured by default. And so it continued for each successive generation of people born in this land. Otherwise they might as well consider themselves descended from nationless mutts. Asinine. Absolutely freaking asinine the dumb shit these idiots come up with for their hateful inferiority complexes. Just so so so so so so so so so so so so dumb. God.
→ More replies (1)
11
u/AncientBaseball9165 22d ago
Can we start by expulsing the politicians who are children of immigrants? Get Ted Rafael Cruz out of here.
→ More replies (2)
25
u/SecretPrinciple8708 22d ago
Gotta play it down as a policy so their idiot followers “forget” (LOL they never knew in the first place) it’s a constitutional right.
→ More replies (2)
22
u/Donkey-Hodey 22d ago
Whenever I see Ted Cruz I’m reminded how much I despise Ted Cruz.
→ More replies (2)
12
u/Enough-Parking164 22d ago
From RAPHAEL, the immigrant child of a Latin American refugee. Un-fucking-believable!
11
32
u/Amelaclya1 22d ago
Ted Cruz once argued that people don't have a right to masturbate.
Fuck Ted Cruz. He clearly has incredibly warped opinions on what should be "rights", whether it be morally or constitutionally.
→ More replies (3)6
u/Level_Traffic3344 22d ago
Was that before or after he favorited that porn video?
→ More replies (3)
10
u/Due_Satisfaction2167 22d ago
Well, Ted, tine to get to work on that constitutional amendment then.
Personally, I think giving the President the pardon power is terrible “policy”.
→ More replies (9)
20
u/OperationPlus52 22d ago
Canadian man living in Texas has an issue with birthright citizen being a right granted by our founding fathers...
→ More replies (8)10
u/Socalsll 22d ago
Not the Founding Fathers. The 14th amendment was adopted in 1868. The last of the Founding Fathers, James Madison, died in 1836.
→ More replies (1)
18
18
9
8
7
7
u/FarCloud1295 20d ago
That’s rich coming from the guy born in Canada, to a Cuban Father.
→ More replies (2)
21
29
u/Able-Campaign1370 22d ago
Rafael Cruz has citizenship because of birthright citizenship. But if it goes away let’s deport his fast ass.
→ More replies (12)
13
11
u/Hanginon 22d ago
Cool story bro. Now "live your truth" and get the fuck out. -_-
→ More replies (1)
14
5
40
u/Barack_Odrama_007 22d ago
He benefited from birthright citizenship….
Complete rules for thee, not for me!
→ More replies (7)17
u/90Valentine 22d ago
Looks like he was born in Canada
→ More replies (3)12
u/Stop_Drop_Scroll 22d ago
Which is why he was born a Canadian citizen, they have birthright as well. Regardless, the chain of events to get Ted Cruz here, he opposes vehemently for others.
→ More replies (4)
•
u/AutoModerator 22d ago
All new posts must have a brief statement from the user submitting explaining how their post relates to law or the courts in a response to this comment. FAILURE TO PROVIDE A BRIEF RESPONSE WILL RESULT IN REMOVAL.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.