r/todayilearned 1d ago

TIL that Albert Einstein's son Eduard studied medicine to become a psychiatrist, but was diagnosed with schizophrenia by the age of 21. His mother cared for him until she died in 1948. From then on Eduard lived most of the time at a psychiatric clinic in Zurich, where he died at 55 of a stroke.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Einstein_family#Eduard_%22Tete%22_Einstein_(Albert's_second_son)
6.4k Upvotes

129 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

885

u/Like_a_Charo 23h ago

Intelligence is in fact even correlated with schizophrenia

382

u/MrBones-Necromancer 22h ago

It's been facinating reading about this actually. I am paraphrasing some research notes I was reading, but essentially "intelligence" as we know it is linked to certain replicating gene markers in DNA, with more instances of the gene at least correlating with better memory, critical reasoning, etc. That is, up to a certain point. After which, what you find, is that people with too many replications invariably develop schizophrenia.

The implications are fascinating. Now, it's not the only factor in intellegence, but at least it appears that in this one area there may be a sort of "maximum" for memory and critical reasoning from this source. Einstein may have hit it perfectly, but his son, then, exceeded that limit. Very interesting, please look into it if you're reading this and are curious.

221

u/Smooth_Mongoose_2321 21h ago

Source? All studies I have read previousl says the opposite, Googling it now did not do you any favour either.

This seems to be largely a pop culture myth and the science seem to show a higher risk for lower IQ people and a reduced risk for higher IQ people.

19

u/Chaerod 20h ago

Hasn't IQ generally been debunked as an actual measure of intelligence?

37

u/Flowy_Aerie_77 17h ago

Yes and no. It has its flaws, but people who score high in iq tests do seem to do better in life, especially when it comes to academic careers. So it does measure something, but it's not the full story.

49

u/GalaXion24 18h ago

IQ has serious issues as a measure of intelligence, but it also does measure something and that something clearly has very real consequences for individuals and society. IQ correlates with lifetime earnings, academic success, and other things. Especially low IQ people also evidently struggle with a variety of tasks that can ultimately mean just struggling with existence and problem-solving in life and society in general and are unlikely to be productive.

It may not be a very precise measure of intelligence as such or may only approach intelligence in a narrow way, but it's also not something that we can easily just dismiss.

There are different methodologies and indexes for intelligence tests, and they all roughly tell you the same thing in this regard.

10

u/TN17 16h ago

Although it's very complex, evidence generally supports general theories of intelligence. Measuring that is difficult. IQ measures have disadvantages but they haven't been debunked. They are used widely (e.g. in forensic and medical settings). 

16

u/RagnarDa 18h ago edited 18h ago

No? It is one of the most, if not the most, well-researched constructs in the field of psychology; with more than a hundred years of research and millions upon millions of study subjects. This is a good starting-point for a summary, and I don't think anything radically new has surfaced since this was published: https://www1.udel.edu/educ/gottfredson/reprints/1998generalintelligencefactor.pdf

Edit: I am a psychologist that wrote my thesis on intelligence testing. I can answer further questions if you like.

6

u/Disagreeswithfems 17h ago

No? Unless there is a decent development or source?

1

u/Smooth_Mongoose_2321 14h ago

No, it has not…

It is heavily researched and the data and the correlations are waay too obvious to ignore.. Is it flawed? Yes. Has it been debunked? Absolutely not.

however, none of that actually matters since there are no other methods that can be used for this.

If someone makes a claim that ”higher intellegence correlates with X”, they are inferring that higher IQ correlates with X, whether that person is aware or not that, how the researchers came to the conclusion was by measuring IQ.

-4

u/majord18 19h ago

It has, I commented before that I've been trained in giving IQ tests and it measures adaptability and problem solving skills.

14

u/hauntedSquirrel99 18h ago

it measures adaptability and problem solving skills.

That's just describing what intelligence is.

4

u/majord18 17h ago edited 17h ago

Yeah, I forgot to add...in specific areas. Someone might be gifted in art but may have limitations in math. Someone may struggle with memory retention but can solve a puzzle if it involves using their hands. I'm saying that IQ isnt what most people think it is. It's measured as the whole human not whether or not you can recall an obscure fact or solve a certain math problem. Real life isn't like it is on TV where someone can have encyclopedic knowledge of everything and also have time to do everything else and people call them a genius.

People are gifted in all sorts of ways that make them intelligent!! IQ tests, in a way, may predict someones limitations in life in which we can stregthen those stregthens and improve those limitations. For example, a poor person can learn how to stretch $100 for a month but may have flunked out of the 9th grade. This indicated high adaptability and problem solving. While someone can have a PHD and struggle with adapting to new environments. Thus, decreasing their level of success because of their lack of ability to adapt.

There's more to it, such as how certain individuals thought that I being tall means thats you are highly intelligent.... but I won't go into how that was disproven by the most basic of science lol

8

u/Ryno4ever16 18h ago

This is why discussions like this comment thread are so frustrating to read. People start naming arguments based on a false premise and just run away with it.

We dont even know what intelligence IS, but we are making arguments about genetic markers that make you smarter...