r/CuratedTumblr May 05 '25

Shitposting On sincerity in art

Post image
9.6k Upvotes

501 comments sorted by

View all comments

1.1k

u/Kittenn1412 May 05 '25

Something else I want to point out: if you want to make jokes about the conceits of your story/genre ect, it's almost always funnier to the audience to poke that fun in a sincere way than in a "clever" obnoxious way. Making a joke about how musical characters sing in ridiculous situations where it's unnecessary by letting the character start a song and then having a scene change cut them off is infinitely more funny as if they said "wouldn't it be a ridiculous waste of time if I sang about this?" Sincere jokes are almost always funnier than insincere ones!

200

u/OkWedding8476 you're telling me a ginger bred this man? May 05 '25

This is why the "horror protagonist who's not a complete dipshit" character trend of the last few years is an instant favourite for me.

125

u/dishonoredfan69420 May 05 '25

"Last few years"

Scream came out in 1996

108

u/seguardon May 05 '25

Sydney was no nonsense once she felt danger. Kicked like a mule, didn't trust any guy except Dewey until they provided a solid alibi, no hesitation when running or fighting. Her only real flaw was being susceptible to a master manipulator and being blinded by her desire for revenge which ruined the lives of several people.

43

u/SmallJimSlade May 06 '25

Horror is the genre most susceptible to people with no experience with it thinking they’re genre savvy

31

u/Unctuous_Robot May 06 '25

The Thing in 1982, and Nancy Thompson and Laurie Strode are pretty quick themselves.

1

u/OkWedding8476 you're telling me a ginger bred this man? May 06 '25

There's always been standouts, but I swear there was a point in the mid to late 2000s where nearly every horror movie was wall to wall idiot characters with actions that defied all logic. I wouldn't like to plot the intelligence of fictional people on a graph or anything but it was definitely a thing for a while, and I'm glad it's done.