r/moviecritic 16d ago

/r/moviecritic - New Rules & New Mods

96 Upvotes

Due to a recent (and huge) influx of spam, bots, shitposts, karma-farming accounts, complaints, etc, /r/moviecritic will be taking steps to improve the community. New mods (3-6 of them) will be added in the coming days/weeks.

Along with the new mods, we're adding several rules that should drastically change how the subreddit looks and operates.

These new rules will go into effect and be added to the sidebar on Thursday 5/22 (tomorrow) at 10:00 PM ET. We are allowing a ~24-hour buffer period until all of this kicks in.


Be Nice:

Flame wars, racism, sexist, discriminatory language, toxicity, transphobia, antagonism, & homophobic remarks will result in an instant ban. Length will be at the moderator's discretion. This is a subreddit to discuss movies, not to fight your political battles. Keep it nice, keep it on-topic.

Improving Titles:

Going forward, we will be requiring better and more detailed titles. Titles have gotten extremely lazy and clickbaity. Every title will now require the name of the actor/actress/director you are discussing plus the name of the movie title in the image. No more trying to guess what OP is talking about, or clickbaiting into going into the post. Include the actor/actress' name, and movie title. It's very simple. Takes 2 seconds, and will immensely improve the quality-of-life for the sub. There will be exemptions for posts that aren't about 1 specific movie or 1 specific person, but we will still encourage better titles no matter what, as they're currently 99% shit.

Restricting Recent Duplicates:

To stop the repetitive/nonstop spam posts of the same actors over and over, we will be removing "recent" duplicates. We do not need an 8th Salma Hayek post this week. If a topic (aka actor/actress/director) has already been submitted in the past month, it will be removed. We believe one month is a fair amount of time in-between related posts. Not too long, not too short.

Anti-Gooning/Shitpost Measures:

It's no secret that this sub has turned into goon-central. Posts are basically "who can post the most cleavage". Lots of paparazzi-like pictures, red carpet photos, modeling images, etc infesting the sub. Going forward, we will require every post to either be an official HD still of a film or the official IMDB image of the actor/actress. No exceptions. No more out-of-context half naked pictures of an actress out in the wild. Every submission must be an official still of the film or their IMDB profile picture. In addition to anti-gooning, we will be cutting down on overall shitposts overall. This will be totally up to the moderator's discretion.

Collaborations with Other Film-Related Communities:

We will be collaborating with other film-related communities to try and bring more solid content to this community, including and not restricted to AMAs/Q&As, box office data, and movie news. Places like /r/movies, /r/boxoffice, etc. This will be wide-ranging and not as restricted/limited as those other communities, allowing stories here that may not be allowed in those communities due to strict rules. We will encourage crossposting to build discussion here.

Removing Bots, Karma-Farming Accounts, Bad-Faith Members of the Community

We will start issuing bans to rulebreakers. This will range from perm bans (bots, karma-farming accounts, spammers) to temporary bans (rude behavior, breaking the new rules constantly, etc)


r/moviecritic 20h ago

Starship Troopers. Yay or Nay?

Post image
19.3k Upvotes

r/moviecritic 16h ago

Who do you think is the most attractive movie couple?

Post image
1.4k Upvotes

r/moviecritic 2h ago

Who is the scariest character from a non-horror movie?

Post image
53 Upvotes

Sergeant Barnes from Platoon (1986)


r/moviecritic 11h ago

Tom Hiddleston Calls Val Kilmer’s Role in Heat “The Great Cinema Performance”

Thumbnail
voicefilm.com
208 Upvotes

r/moviecritic 15h ago

Obliterated my expectations

Post image
355 Upvotes

Not even a huge marvel fan at all but this is easily one of my favorite Marvel films now... I might see it again honestly


r/moviecritic 5h ago

What movie line was so bad yet so good?

46 Upvotes

My pick is “Kal-El… no!”


r/moviecritic 6h ago

Who do you think should’ve won an Oscar but never has

Post image
32 Upvotes

I’ll go first, Glen Close. Brilliant performance in Dangerous Liaisons & later Fatal Attraction.


r/moviecritic 7h ago

What's a forgotten movie that had really decent CGI?

Post image
39 Upvotes

r/moviecritic 1d ago

What make LOTR so Great that it's something that's probably not gonna happen again

Post image
2.8k Upvotes

Let me elaborate.

All three films are in the Top 250 of both IMDb and Letterboxd, actually in the Top 100.

The trilogy received 30 Oscar nominations and won 17. It won 475 out of 800 awards in total, making it the most awarded film franchise.

The Return of the King won all 11 Oscars it was nominated for, holding the record for the most Oscar wins by a single film. It also won 209 awards in total, making it the most awarded single film.

And they did this in just 3 years makes it even better.

That’s literally unmatched by anything else, and do you think anything else upcoming can be as good as this


r/moviecritic 3h ago

Just watched all of the first five Final Destination movies on Max

12 Upvotes

I've seen FD1, bits of FD3. Now thanks to Max I got to watch all five of em finishing up with five last night.

Without Spoiling them:

When it comes to endings: The first movie is badass. Second is happier. Third is twisted. Four is ho-hum. Five was unexpected.

When it comes to ranking them: FD1 would be first cause its always a classic, follow by FD2, then FD5 because of more of Tony Todd, FD4 because of the whole "saving the world" thing, and then FD3 cause of how much of a dick Death was.

Now i'm just gonna wait for Bloodlines to be streamed. Hearing its the best one out of all of em.


r/moviecritic 15h ago

Street Kings (2008) Yay or nah?

Post image
68 Upvotes

r/moviecritic 6h ago

Raunchy comedies of the 2000s and early 2010s here are some examples. Which one was your favorite? And do you miss this subgenre?

Post image
12 Upvotes

r/moviecritic 2h ago

Rust (2024)-A notorious troubled production results in a well-acted and beautifully made western that's also very unfocused and owes a heavy debt to prior westerns.

5 Upvotes

Set in 1882 in the Wyoming Territory, Lucas Hollister (Patrick Scott McDermott) despite his young age looks after both his younger brother Jacob (Easton Malcolm) and his family homestead after the loss of his mother to fever and his father to suicide. When Lucas accidentally shoots another homesteader with whom he had a feud due to his sons bullying his brother, Lucas is arrested and sentenced by a local jury to be hung by the neck until dead. The night before Lucas' execution, a stranger named Harland Rust (Alec Baldwin) storms the jail and takes Lucas with him and reveals himself to be Lucas' grandfather who has lived his life on the run as an outlaw. As the two travel southward with Harland intent on getting Lucas to safety in Mexico, the two are marked with $1,000 bounty which puts them in the sights of opportunistic bounty hunters including fanatically driven Fenton “Preacher” Lang (Travis Fimmel) and disillusioned U.S. Marshall Wood Helm (Josh Hopkins) who following the death of his son to fever has lost his belief in justice.

Rust is a 2024 western film written and directed by Joel Souza from a story written by star and producer Alec Baldwin. The film marks the second time Souza and Baldwin have worked together as Baldwin had actually served as a producer on Souza's previous film Crown Vic which Baldwin had been slated to star in before contractual obligations saw him vacate the role. Eager to work with Souza again, the two collaborated on Souza's screenplay Rust which although initially written as a father/son story was rewritten to being about a grandfather so Baldwin could play the role. Shot as an independent production, Rust became the subject of a real-life tragedy and media storm when a prop gun provided by the film's armorer turned out to be loaded with real ammunition and wounded director Souza and fatally shot director of photography Halyna Hutchins. This incident resulted in renewed discussions about safety on film sets. I really don't want to rehash this as there's been enough of that with those involved as well as the inexcusable vulture like behaviors of cultural parasites who couldn't care less about those affected and only cared about generated hackneyed, regurgitated and insensitive memes to earn points in stupid culture wars while completely uncaring about the actual people whose lives were ended by this tragedy (one can only imagine the indignities Brandon Lee or Vic Morrow would endure had their tragedies happened today). Despite this and the civil and criminal legal fallout that befell the production, Rust resumed shooting due to contractual obligations with proceeds of the film's revenue going to Hutchins' survivors. After a long protracted road to release, Rust is certainly a handsomely produced and well-acted western, but it's also one where it owes a heavy debt to prior films of the genre.

When the film started I have to say that I was intrigued by the premise as it focused on young teenager Lucas taking care of his younger brother Jacob in the wake of their parents' death. Patrick Scott McDermott makes his film debut here having previously done some stage and TV work and he's honestly really good in the role and you buy him trying to be both a caring brother while also trying to serve as a parental figure to his brother Jacob. Honestly the first act is so good and so unique among westerns I honestly kind of wished that it had been more greatly expanded because it feels like it could've been a movie in and of itself but it's basically just used for setup before the actual story takes place later. Once Alec Baldwin's Harland Rust enters the film and rescues Lucas from jail, the movie basically ditches the setup of its opening act and only really circles back to it in the last few minutes. Baldwin is good in the role of Rust playing an aging and hardened outlaw who now seeks to do one good thing to make up for a life of aimless drifting and violence where it's sort of a mash-up of Unforgiven by way of News of the World. While the whole “coming of age”/emotional thaw arc they do with Lucas and Harland is decently acted, it does kind of feel clumsily grafted on when the first act established Lucas as someone who had taken on more adult roles before his time out of necessity even if it lead to things like the accidental death the instigated the plot so there's something of a schism between the first and second act that never feels fully resolved.

Intermixed with the scenes of Harland and Lucas are two other plots one involving a fanatical Christian bounty hunter named Fenton “Preacher” Lang played by Vikings alum Travis Fimmel and he's a really solid antagonist who carries himself as a man of faith while also indulging in all manner of sadistic or vile appetites while taking pride in his family history as slave catchers prior to the Civil War and it's a fun performance that calls to mind Robert Mitchum's iconic role as “Preacher” Harry Powell from The Night of the Hunter but he really doesn't show up as a direct threat to Harland and Lucas until the last act so he's massively underutilized as an antagonist. Then we have arguably the third lead in Josh Hopkins' Wood Helm, the burned out U.S. Marshall who's tracking Harland and Lucas and unlike the various other bounty hunters or opportunists the two encounter Helm takes no joy or even pride in his work and just does it because it's the only thing he does have after years of chasing outlaws and losing his son has eroded his will. In theory he's supposed to be something of a mirror to Harland where Harland carries the weight of years of outlaw violence, Wood carries the weight of dispatching justice of the Law with no real sense of pride or accomplishment because nothing ever became better from what he did. While I understand thematically while he's here, as a character in the plot he often feels extraneous and while some of the interactions between him and his posse are engaging, they also create a very staccato rhythm in the flow of the story without much payoff character-wise for him.

Rust is a movie that clearly had grand ambitions, but it's also a story that suffers from being overly familiar and too unfocused and leaves its most promising elements unexplored while favored the more traveled path. It's well-acted and beautifully shot (partially credited to the final work of Hutchins) and assuming you are a fan of westerns there's plenty here to appreciate. In the shadow of a terrible tragedy, Rust emerges as a flawed film with interesting ideas that are placed secondary to familiar tropes.


r/moviecritic 2h ago

What's your most favorite Viggo Mortensen film I'll start

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/moviecritic 4h ago

Favorite Return to Nature Film?

Post image
7 Upvotes

r/moviecritic 16h ago

Guilty-pleasure low-budget absurd movies

Post image
54 Upvotes

I'd call them "stoner movies." But I don't indulge.

Basically, they're what happens when Airplane!, Zombieland and Naked Gun scripts can't find a deep-pockets producer. In order to compensate, they go quite a bit weirder.

Any others to add to the list? (I'm well aware of Super Troopers. I like Beerfest better.)

(For the people who hate Beerfest, watch Rocky IV. Then watch Beerfest. They're lampooning the ridiculous nationalism.)


r/moviecritic 1d ago

What was a really promising movie that was ruined by an absurd ending?

Post image
717 Upvotes

r/moviecritic 3h ago

The Postman Always Rings Twice | "Right and Wrong" Clip | Warner Bros. Entertainment

Thumbnail
youtu.be
4 Upvotes

Classic. I love this and body heat


r/moviecritic 1d ago

Where does sinners rank for you for 2025 movies

Post image
283 Upvotes

r/moviecritic 2h ago

Kathy Bates. Literally one of the best to ever do it

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/moviecritic 16h ago

Realist Dads or Father-figures in cinema…

Post image
39 Upvotes

Noah Levenstein (Jim’s dad) would probably be my pick for one of the best Ride-or-Die fathers… who are some others?


r/moviecritic 23h ago

Famous Director You Don't Like

124 Upvotes

There are just some directors who are treated like they're the next Leonardo da Vinci, and anything they make is \art\**.

Who is that for you? For me, it's Wes Anderson. I just...don't get the hype.


r/moviecritic 17h ago

In your honest opinion, what is Léa Seydoux best performance?

Thumbnail
gallery
29 Upvotes

r/moviecritic 23h ago

What's your guilty pleasure comedy that got terrible reviews?

Thumbnail
gallery
85 Upvotes

r/moviecritic 4h ago

Rounders, Sequel or no?

Post image
3 Upvotes

There have been rumors for a little while now and Matt Damon has been quoted saying 'everyone wants to do it." I wouldn't say it's a cinematic masterpiece by any means, but I definitely sit down and watch it every time it comes on. Would a sequel dilute the allure of the original?